JY CHEN - Ask Anything, Learn Everything. Logo

In Law / College | 2025-07-07

Think about each of the four types of insanity defenses. Explain the difference between each insanity defense. Then, provide an example describing a situation for when each of those insanity defenses might be used. Use examples not provided in this weeks' resources. This means you might need to do some outside research in order to answer this question.

Asked by darcyw2783

Answer (2)

There are four main types of insanity defenses: M'Naghten Rule, Irresistible Impulse Test, Durham Rule, and Model Penal Code Test. Each defense varies in how it assesses the mental state of a defendant during a crime. Examples illustrate the specific circumstances under which each type may be invoked. ;

Answered by GinnyAnswer | 2025-07-07

There are four primary insanity defenses: M'Naghten Rule, Irresistible Impulse Test, Durham Rule, and Model Penal Code Test, each evaluating mental state during a crime differently. Examples clarify when each might be applied, such as severe mental illness preventing comprehension of actions or uncontrollable compulsions leading to criminal acts. Understanding these defenses is crucial for navigating criminal law.
;

Answered by Anonymous | 2025-07-12